Black Friday 2025 trends paint a peculiar picture: Americans spent more money while claiming they’d spend less. Record crowds, rising prices, and cautious rhetoric collided in a five-day shopping marathon that exposed the gap between what we tell ourselves about money and what we actually do with it.
TL;DR: The essentials
- A record 202.9 million people shopped from Thanksgiving through Cyber Monday, up from 197 million shoppers last year and surpassing the previous record of 200.4 million set in 2023, even as many said they wanted to cut back.
- Online spending for the five days hit $44.2 billion, up 7.7% from 2024, while average selling prices jumped 7% according to Salesforce, with order volume declining 1%.
- Most money went to gifts and gift cards, while travel and dining out took a hit as households tried to stretch tighter budgets.
- The real lesson: without a clear holiday budget and plan, even “cautious” shoppers end up financing gifts well into the new year.
Most analysis of Black Friday gets it backwards. Experts focus on retail health, economic indicators, and consumer confidence scores. But the real story isn’t about the economy, it’s about the disconnect between intention and action that defines most personal finance failures.
Think you were cautious this year because you comparison-shopped and waited for deals? The data suggests otherwise. What Black Friday 2025 actually revealed was a masterclass in self-deception: millions of shoppers convinced themselves they were being frugal while breaking spending records. Understanding this gap between perception and reality might be the most valuable financial insight you gain all year.
Black Friday 2025 trends: record crowds, pricier carts
The numbers tell a story no one wants to hear. The National Retail Federation reported 202.9 million U.S. shoppers between Thanksgiving and Cyber Monday, beating 2024’s record of 197 million and demolishing its own forecast of 186.9 million. Black Friday alone drew 80.3 million in-store shoppers and 85.7 million online.
Adobe Analytics tracked online spending at $44.2 billion across the five days, up 7.7% year over year. Cyber Monday alone hit $14.25 billion, up 7.1% year over year. But buried in the celebration was an uncomfortable fact: Salesforce reported average selling prices jumped 7% with order volume declining 1% versus Black Friday 2024.
The contradiction couldn’t be clearer. Record participation. Record spending. Higher prices on nearly everything. Yet surveys showed most shoppers believed they were being more careful than ever. This wasn’t just shopping, it was collective financial delusion on a national scale.
What people actually bought (and what they skipped)
NRF data exposed the hierarchy of holiday priorities. The average shopper dropped $337.86 over the long weekend, up from $315.56 in 2024. Approximately 67% ($225.74) was spent on gifts. Clothing and accessories dominated (51% of shoppers), followed by toys (32%), books and media (28%), and gift cards (26%).
PwC’s holiday outlook crowned gift cards as the compromise champion: 52% planned to give them to friends, 47% to family. Food and consumable gifts held steady at 26–28% of shoppers, practical presents for uncertain times.
The casualties were predictable but telling. Travel budgets and dining out took significant hits as households tried to stretch tighter budgets. The message was clear: protect the gift pile, sacrifice everything else.
The “cautious but overspending” paradox
PwC discovered that 84% of consumers planned to cut back over the next six months, citing rising prices, new tariffs and the higher cost of living. They targeted dining out (52%), clothing (36%), and big-ticket items (32%) for the chopping block. They armed themselves with price trackers, comparison apps, and waited for specific promotions. They told themselves they were being smart.
Then they broke spending records anyway.
The mechanisms of this failure are predictable:
- Skipping one major purchase creates a false sense of virtue that justifies a dozen smaller splurges.
- “Limited-time” messaging triggers primal urgency that overrides rational planning.
- Buy-now-pay-later schemes disguise true costs by fragmenting them across future months.
Retailers understand something shoppers refuse to admit: budgeting isn’t about intelligence or information. It’s about recognizing that your emotional brain will always overpower your rational brain unless you create systems that remove the decision entirely.
Why it matters for your budget
January credit card statements don’t lie. That $340 weekend plus December’s final push can easily create a four-figure hangover that lingers for months. Current interest rates make this math particularly brutal, carry a $1,500 balance at typical credit card rates and you’re still paying for those 2025 purchases when 2026’s Black Friday arrives.
The opportunity cost compounds the damage. Every dollar servicing holiday debt is a dollar not building your emergency fund, not invested for retirement, not working toward actual financial security. The pattern repeats annually because most people treat holiday spending as somehow separate from their “real” financial life, a dangerous fiction that keeps them trapped.
Holiday budgeting lessons from Black Friday 2025
Black Friday isn’t a shopping event. It’s a behavioral experiment that exposes how you really handle money under pressure.
The first revelation: timing beats willpower. Retailers stretched deals across November, diluting the urgency while maximizing spend. Smart shoppers could exploit this by spreading purchases across the month, comparing prices without time pressure. The Finhabits’ guide to starting a 2026 budget reset shows how monthly planning creates space for strategic purchasing instead of reactive grabbing.
The second insight: specificity defeats vagueness. “Spend less” is meaningless. “$400 for gifts, $300 for travel, $150 for dining” creates enforceable boundaries. The framework in Finhabits’ article on avoiding holiday debt demonstrates how category caps transform good intentions into actual restraint.
The third truth: future planning prevents present panic. If credit or buy-now-pay-later is part of your strategy, those payments need slots in your January, February, and March budgets before November arrives. Otherwise you’re just surprising your future self with bills you pretended wouldn’t exist.
What to do before the next Black Friday (or next “shopping” season)
Actual change requires actual systems, not better intentions:
- Write your total holiday spending limit. Break it into specific categories. Make the tradeoffs visible before emotions take over.
- Determine your maximum acceptable credit usage and minimum payoff speed. Calculate the true cost including interest.
- Create a holiday sinking fund. Automatic monthly transfers remove the willpower requirement.
- Institute a 24-hour pause on any purchase over $50. Urgency is manufactured, deals repeat.
Two of these changes would transform your next holiday season. All four would make you unrecognizable to retailers who count on your predictable weakness.
Connecting Black Friday choices to your long-term goals
The same impulses that destroy holiday budgets also sabotage retirement accounts, emergency funds, and investment strategies. Fear of missing out doesn’t just empty your cart, it drives market timing attempts and panic selling.
Finhabits regularly examines these broader patterns, from analyzing a divided economy and rising layoffs in November 2025 to explaining why market volatility can still fit into a long-term plan. The discipline that prevents Black Friday disasters also prevents investment disasters.
Consider this reframe: match holiday spending with automated investing. For every dollar allocated to gifts, route a percentage to your future.
Holiday spending tradeoffs at a glance
| Choice | Short-term feeling | Impact on your budget | Better alternative |
|---|---|---|---|
| Impulse flash-sale purchase | Excitement and FOMO relief | Higher card balance and interest | 24-hour pause before buying |
| No total holiday limit | Feels flexible in the moment | Sticker shock in January | Written total and category caps |
| Only minimum card payments | Lower payment today | Debt lingers for many months | Planned payoff in 3–4 cycles |
| Skipping savings in November | More cash for gifts now | Slower progress on long-term goals | Keep small automatic contributions |
| No holiday sinking fund | No effort during the year | Heavy hit to one paycheck | Set aside a set amount monthly |
FAQ: Black Friday 2025 trends and your wallet
Did Black Friday 2025 trends show people really spending less?
The opposite happened. PwC surveys showed most people intended to cut back, yet NRF and Adobe tracked record participation and spending. The disconnect reveals how higher prices, expanded online deals, and accumulated small purchases overwhelm good intentions that lack concrete enforcement mechanisms.
Why did travel spending decline while gift spending stayed strong?
Data exposed a clear priority: households protected gift-giving while slashing discretionary experiences. Gift and gift card spending remained sacred, even among higher-income households who could afford both.
How can I use Black Friday data to build a better budget?
Treat the $338 average weekend spending as a diagnostic. Did your amount feel worth the January statement shock? Set category caps before emotion takes over. Decide credit limits in advance. Build those payments into your next three monthly budgets. The data shows what happens without structure, use it to build yours.
How can Finhabits help me prepare for the 2026 holiday season?
Finhabits offers educational articles and tools that help you reset your budget, automate contributions toward long-term goals, and stay focused when the economy feels uncertain. Exploring pieces like our holiday debt guide or our 2026 budget reset article is a simple way to start planning earlier. Plus, Emma—your virtual financial planner inside Finhabits—can help you track spending patterns, set realistic holiday savings targets, and stay accountable week by week so you don’t start the season unprepared.
Turn this year’s Black Friday lessons into next year’s plan
Holiday sales expose the gap between financial intentions and financial behavior. The same discipline that could protect you from Black Friday manipulation can build your long-term wealth, if you create systems instead of relying on willpower.
Explore your next step: start with Finhabits resources like five ways to avoid holiday debt or a simple 2026 budget reset and begin shaping a calmer holiday season.
Conclusion
Black Friday 2025 numbers didn’t reveal consumer trends, it revealed consumer delusions. Record crowds spent record amounts at higher prices while believing they were being cautious. The gap between perception and reality explains why January credit card statements surprise people who should know better.
The solution isn’t better deals or stronger willpower. It’s recognizing that holiday spending is just another financial decision that requires structure, limits, and advance planning. Set your boundaries before retailers set them for you.
Next November will bring the same psychological triggers, the same “limited-time” urgency, the same rationalization opportunities. What changes is whether you walk in with a system or walk out with regret.
Sources
- CNBC – Holiday shopping turnout jumps to 202.9 million people during Thanksgiving weekend, NRF says
- National Retail Federation – Thanksgiving Holiday Weekend Draws a Record 203 Million Shoppers
- Adobe – Cyber Monday Hits Record $14.25 Billion in Online Spending
- CNN Business – You’re paying more for less this shopping season. Now there’s proof
- PwC – Holiday Outlook 2025
- SIPC – What SIPC Protects
All sources accessed and verified on December 4, 2025. External links open in new window.
Disclaimer: This material is provided for informational purposes only and is not intended to offer investment, legal, or tax advice. All images and figures are for illustrative purposes. Investment advisory services are offered through Finhabits Advisors LLC, a registered investment advisor with the SEC. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. Past performance is not indicative of future returns. All investments involve risk, including the possible loss of principal. Securities are offered through Apex Clearing Corporation, Member of FINRA, SIPC. Securities held at Apex are protected up to $500,000, which includes a $250,000 cash limit. See SIPC.org for more details.
Projections are for educational and illustrative purposes only. They are based on the assumptions stated and will change if those assumptions change. They do not predict or reflect the actual performance of any Finhabits portfolio, and they do not account for economic, market, or individual financial factors that can impact real investment outcomes.
© Finhabits, Inc. All rights reserved.
